Case Study:
Plagiarism and Academic Integrity
Written by Joe Marzo
Plagiarism in academics is a serious problem that can have severe consequences for students. It involves using someone else's work or ideas without giving them proper credit. This not only academic integrity but also undermines the purpose of education, which is to learn and develop critical thinking skills. Plagiarism can result in failing grades, suspension, or even expulsion from school. It is important for students to understand the consequences of plagiarism and to learn how to properly cite sources to avoid it.
Case Study: Plagiarism and Academic Integrity
Scenario:
John is a second-year university student majoring in computer science. This semester has been particularly challenging for him due to a combination of personal issues, part-time work, and a heavy course load. Faced with the pressure of an upcoming deadline for his ethics course essay, John feels overwhelmed and desperate. He searches online and finds an essay that closely matches the topic he needs to address. Despite knowing the risks, he decides to copy significant portions of the essay and submits it as his own.
​
A week later, John's professor, Dr. Adams, who has been teaching the course for over a decade, notices inconsistencies in the writing style and suspects plagiarism. Dr. Adams uses a plagiarism detection tool, which confirms that large sections of John’s essay were copied from an online source without proper attribution. Dr. Adams schedules a meeting with John to discuss the issue.
​
During the meeting, John admits to the plagiarism but explains the extreme stress and pressure he was under. He pleads for leniency, expressing regret and promising to never do it again. Dr. Adams must decide how to handle the situation, considering both the importance of upholding academic integrity and the personal circumstances John is facing. The university’s policy on plagiarism mandates severe consequences, including potential suspension.
​
Reflection Questions:
-
Ethical Analysis: What are the ethical implications of John’s actions? Consider the impact on academic integrity, fairness to other students, and John's personal circumstances.
-
Decision-Making: How should Dr. Adams address the situation with John, balancing empathy and the need to uphold academic standards? What factors should be considered in determining an appropriate response?
-
Consequences: What are the potential academic and personal consequences for John if he is punished according to university policy? How might this affect his future academic and professional career?
-
Preventive Measures: How can universities better educate students about the importance of academic integrity and the risks associated with plagiarism? What support systems could be put in place to help students like John who are struggling?
-
Policy Evaluation: Should universities have a one-size-fits-all policy for plagiarism, or should there be flexibility to consider individual circumstances? Discuss the pros and cons of each approach.