Ethical Case Study: 
The Lehman Brothers Collapse

Case Study: The Lehman Brothers Collapse

Background:

​

Lehman Brothers, a storied institution founded in 1850, grew from a humble dry-goods store to a global financial services powerhouse. Over its 158-year history, Lehman Brothers became a key player in investment banking, trading, research, private equity, and asset management. Its journey from a family business to one of Wall Street's giants symbolized the evolution of the American financial system.

​

In the early 2000s, Lehman Brothers aggressively expanded its business into the booming real estate market. The firm heavily invested in subprime mortgages, which were loans offered to borrowers with low credit ratings. These high-risk mortgages were packaged into mortgage-backed securities (MBS) and collateralized debt obligations (CDOs), which Lehman sold to investors. This strategy brought substantial short-term profits and propelled Lehman to the forefront of the financial industry.

​

However, Lehman's aggressive growth strategy came with significant risks. The firm's leverage ratio—essentially the amount of debt it took on compared to its equity—soared. High leverage can amplify profits, but it also magnifies losses, making firms vulnerable to market downturns. Lehman's exposure to subprime mortgages made it particularly susceptible to the housing market's fluctuations.

​

By 2007, the U.S. housing market showed signs of strain. Housing prices began to fall, and mortgage delinquencies and defaults started to rise. The value of MBS and CDOs plummeted, and the financial institutions holding these securities faced severe losses. Lehman Brothers, deeply entrenched in the subprime market, found itself at the epicenter of this emerging crisis.

​

As the housing market collapsed, Lehman's financial position deteriorated rapidly. The firm reported significant losses and struggled to raise capital. Despite attempts to offload toxic assets and secure strategic partnerships, confidence in Lehman's solvency waned. The firm's stock price tumbled, and its credit ratings were downgraded, further exacerbating its liquidity crisis.

​

In March 2008, the collapse of Bear Stearns, another major investment bank, sent shockwaves through the financial system. Bear Stearns was acquired by JPMorgan Chase with the assistance of the Federal Reserve, highlighting the fragility of financial institutions heavily exposed to subprime mortgages. Lehman Brothers was next in line, but the government's willingness to intervene was less certain.

​

Throughout the summer of 2008, Lehman continued to seek a buyer or significant capital infusion. Potential deals with the Korea Development Bank and Bank of America fell through. As Lehman's financial condition worsened, so did the broader financial markets' anxiety. The firm's survival became a barometer for the health of the global financial system.

On September 10, 2008, Lehman announced a staggering $3.9 billion loss for the third quarter, primarily due to write-downs on commercial and residential real estate assets. The firm’s efforts to raise capital, including spinning off commercial real estate assets into a separate company, failed to restore confidence. Over the following days, Lehman’s stock plummeted, and its credit default swaps (a form of insurance against default) soared, indicating an imminent collapse.

​

With no private sector solution in sight, Lehman Brothers filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection on September 15, 2008. The bankruptcy filing was the largest in U.S. history, involving $639 billion in assets. The collapse of Lehman Brothers had immediate and profound effects. It triggered a global financial crisis, leading to a severe credit crunch, massive job losses, and a deep recession. The financial system's interconnectedness meant that Lehman's failure reverberated through banks, businesses, and economies worldwide.

​

In the aftermath, extensive investigations and analyses were conducted to understand the collapse's causes and implications. The Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission identified multiple factors, including excessive risk-taking, regulatory failures, and corporate governance deficiencies. Lehman's collapse highlighted the perils of high leverage, inadequate risk management, and the dangers of a financial system dependent on short-term funding and complex financial products.

​

The crisis also led to significant regulatory reforms. The Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act was enacted in 2010 to increase oversight of financial institutions, enhance consumer protections, and reduce the likelihood of future financial crises. The Act included provisions to regulate derivatives, increase transparency, and establish mechanisms for resolving failing financial institutions without resorting to taxpayer-funded bailouts.

The Lehman Brothers collapse remains a pivotal moment in financial history, serving as a cautionary tale of the dangers of unchecked ambition, inadequate oversight, and the fragility of the global financial system.

​

Key Players:

• Richard Fuld: CEO of Lehman Brothers during its collapse.

• Federal Reserve and U.S. Treasury: Government bodies involved in the crisis response.

Timeline of Events:

2003-2007:

Lehman Brothers heavily invests in subprime mortgage-backed securities.

​

2007: The housing market collapses, and Lehman begins to suffer financial losses.

​

March 2008:

Bear Stearns is acquired by JPMorgan Chase with Federal Reserve assistance, raising concerns about Lehman's solvency.

​

September 10, 2008:

Lehman announces a $3.9 billion loss for the third quarter and attempts to sell assets to raise capital.

September 15, 2008:

Lehman Brothers files for bankruptcy after failing to secure a bailout or buyout.

​

September 2008:

The financial crisis intensifies, leading to government interventions, including the Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP).

​

Ethical Issues:

Risk Management: Lehman Brothers took excessive risks by heavily investing in subprime mortgages without adequate risk management practices.

Transparency and Disclosure: The firm failed to fully disclose the extent of its exposure to subprime mortgages and the associated risks to investors and regulators.

Corporate Governance: Lehman's board of directors and senior management did not effectively oversee the company's risk-taking activities and strategic decisions.

Regulatory Oversight: Regulatory bodies failed to adequately monitor and address the growing risks within Lehman Brothers and the broader financial system.

Analysis Questions:

1. Do you think the corporate culture at Lehman Brothers contributed to the excessive risk-taking that led to its collapse? Why or why not?

2. In your opinion, should the responsibility for Lehman Brothers' collapse rest more on the company's executives, the board of directors, or the regulators? Explain your reasoning.

3. What steps do you think financial institutions should take to ensure better risk management and prevent similar collapses in the future?

4. How can regulatory bodies improve their oversight and enforcement to detect and mitigate excessive risk-taking in financial institutions?

5. Do you think the collapse of Lehman Brothers will have a long-term impact on the financial industry’s approach to risk management and corporate governance? Why or why not?